I’ve directed two theatre productions so far, meaning I had to sit through auditions and make casting decisions. I also had the opportunity to see many Namibian stage productions and as a film fanatic, over the years I have seen numerous movies; both local and international.
I’d like to think my taste in cinema is pretty much above average. While I really enjoy high-quality movies with big names, I also watch a good variety of indie films with amateur actors. I judge films/plays on 10% storyline, 40% technicality and 50% on acting. Acting can make or break a film or play. A good actor can save a horrible script, whereas a bad actor can destroy a good script. In my opinion, acting is the biggest part of any production. Otherwise, people could just write good scripts and we’d go to the cinema/theatre to listen to the message, but that not really the gig, is it?
From a film perspective, I have seen movies/tv-shows from various industries; Namibia, South Africa, Hollywood, Nollywood and Bollywood, UK, China, etc.. You can tell it is a lot of different cultures and storytelling methods, but the acting is the only thing that really impresses or pisses me off.
So how do you know an actor’s performance is bad? The argument between good and bad acting can be pretty subjective but taking from my own directing/casting background and theatre/film intake, here are the signs of a bad actor:
Bad Actors Speak In A Monotone
You know that thing where an actor is on stage/screen and you are convinced they are reading from a cue card? This type of acting is horrible. Bad actors take the script, rehearse their lines and focus on sounding their lines word for word, without adding any type of personal expressiveness to their speech. If the speed, pitch and delivery of an actor’s dialogue remains the same while they are talking, they are bad at their job.
Bad Actors Are Afraid To Break Down Walls
In order for an actor to be believable, they have to convince their audience by showing, not by saying. An actor can have a very intense script to work with, but if they can’t show how they really feel, they are bad at their job. If an actor is afraid to be vulnerable on stage or on screen, they are bad. A good actor will not be afraid to be embarrassed. For instance, actors who refuse to be in nude or kissing scenes will not really heighten their acting capabilities- not that these equate to good acting, but being comfortable and really selling the character will unlock great acting potential. Actors who hold back are bad at their jobs.
Bad Actors Don’t Know How To Work With Their Castmates
What this means is they just don’t listen to their acting partner. This can especially be detrimental to stage productions. A bad actor is only focused on remembering and delivering their lines, so much that they don’t care what their dialogue partner said, they will blindly deliver their next line without properly reacting to what the other actor said. A bad actor is only focused on looking good on camera or stage, they don’t care about their fellow castmates.